I have been watching a fair bit of YouTube videos (as I am prone to do) and I have noticed a couple of trends on the site. I don’t think either one would surprise anyone. The first is a huge increase in AI-developed content. A lot of this is AI-enhanced, but quite a lot of it seems as if it is without human creative vision. It is fun sometimes to watch the errors stream out. This does not imply that humans don’t make errors, but a lot of the AI errors can be quite glaring. But you know all of this. The second one is more interesting. The second trend is the rebellion against this trend by a vocal minority. This is seen by:
- The coining of the phrase “AI Slop” online for “content” that is predominantly AI created.
- Community shaming of people who use AI for visuals, music, voiceover, and especially thumbnails.
- YouTube personalities who are specifically targeting AI channels for ridicule and promoting those who fight the trend.
- Many channels where the main creator was identified only by a voice are now putting themselves in front of the camera to show that they are not AI.
- Some people who are creating art will also attach visual evidence showing how they created it themselves.
I watched a couple of videos about AI that I found quite helpful today.
A. One was “Why I Hate AI Writing” by The Closer Look. The video is AVAILABLE HERE. In that, the creator puts himself in front of the camera, something I don’t think he ever did until recently. In his arguments against AI in writing, he believes that there is, and always will be, a percentage of the population that will desire AUTHENTICITY. Many simply do want to hear the ideas of creative thinkers and communicators. These people do not want to read, view, or watch an algorithmically-driven “crowdshare” of data.
Authenticity is difficult to define, much like obsenity, but you “know it when you see it.” I was raised near an Amish (Old Order Mennonite) community. Many of them have cottage industries on their farms, like baked goods, leatherwork, and furniture. When we were back home visiting, we would like to visit some of these homes/shops. Once we stopped at an Amish home selling homemade candies and goat milk fudge. While there, a teenage member of the family who was taking care of our purchases asked us, “People drive here and buy stuff from us, but why do you all do that?” It is a good question, and I don’t think we gave all that great of an answer. Perhaps some of it is a bit of nostalgia. My grandparents and great grandparents were farmers who lived not all that different from them… but for our family, that time has passed. But I think part of the reason is AUTHENTICITY. When we buy a pie from an Amish bakery, we see who baked it, and where it was baked and know that this was handmade by people who cared about what they were doing, having learned their skills from the generation before and passing those same skills to the next generation, and doing it to sustain their family’s well-being. This contrasts greatly with buying a pie in a store, where you go through layers of machines to soulless corporations whose primary concern is stockholder value. While it is run by people and worked by people, it simply feels inauthentic.
Will most people truly choose authentic over inauthentic. Problably not. But authentic is something that a sizable amount of the population will always crave.
B. Another video was “The AI Takeover has completely backfired” by Damon Cassidy. The video is AVAILABLE HERE. Despite the way the title seems to imply, he does not believe that AI is going to collapse or become unimportant. (I must be honest, my next point may have come from Damon, or from Henry at The Closer Look… I forget.) He sees the online world with AI potentially becoming a “desert landscape” of creativity. That is, creativity is lacking as crowdsourcing software just shuffles and combines previous content based on people’s tastes. This “landscape of death” is not total, however. There will be OASES OF CREATIVITY, where human creativity shines through.
For me, after dabbling a bit with AI a couple of years ago, have decided to stop. There are a few reasons:
A. I have seen what happens to people who have switched from the rigor of research and creating actual work to coming up with good prompts. All too often such people struggle to even draw the energy to proofread what they prompted into existence. That is not who I want to be.
B. It is mentally stimulating to do things the hard way. This is almost a reworking of the previous point, but for me it is specifically applicable, as I am in my 60s. I would like to stave off mental degradation and ossification for a few more years. I don’t see GenAI as my path to staving off this decline.
C. Related to getting older, the argument that I must get aboard the AI train because it is the future doesn’t really apply to me that much. I can probably get away with doing things the old-fashioned way in most situations without ruining my probable future.
D. If it does become true that AI takes over the Internet, then I want to be a creative “oasis in the desert.” If being such an oasis attracts only a few people and lots of bots mining my thoughts for generative AI, I think I can accept that tiny influence footprint.
E. I spent decades doing my best to play what games I needed to to survive and perhaps thrive. Now, I think I want to embrace authenticity. Authenticity in the end is just another act of protest against a culture of inauthenticity.




